When a Patient Asks to Go Out on Disability: A Practical Guide for Nurse Practitioners
Being asked to “take a patient out on disability” is an extremely common part of primary care — and one that often creates uncertainty for nurse practitioners, especially early in practice. The request can feel vague and high-stakes at the same time, particularly when it’s not clear what the patient is actually asking for or what role you’re expected to play.
Before getting into the details, it’s important to name one thing clearly: this post is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Scope of practice, documentation authority, and disability-related responsibilities vary by state and by organization. Clinicians should always follow their local laws, clinic policies, and institutional guidance.
With that in mind, understanding how disability systems work — and where primary care fits — can make these conversations far more manageable.
What Patients Usually Mean When They Say “Go on Disability”
In primary care, patients often use the word disability as shorthand. They may be referring to time off work, employer-based disability benefits, or Social Security Disability. Each of these pathways operates differently and involves different decision-makers.
Clarifying what the patient means early in the conversation is often the most helpful first step. Asking what their employer, insurer, or another entity has asked them to do can quickly narrow the scope of the request and prevent misunderstandings.
How Disability Works in the United States
In the U.S., primary care clinicians do not determine whether a patient qualifies for disability benefits. Nurse practitioners evaluate and treat medical conditions, assess functional impact, and document clinical findings. Decisions about disability eligibility are made by employers, insurance companies, or the Social Security Administration, depending on the pathway involved.
This distinction is essential. Patients may understandably feel like their primary care clinician is the gatekeeper, but administratively and legally, that is not the case.
Common Disability Pathways Patients May Be Navigating
Employer-Based Leave and FMLA
Some patients are asking about job-protected leave rather than long-term disability. The Family and Medical Leave Act is a federal program that allows eligible employees to take unpaid leave for certain medical conditions. Many states also have additional family and medical leave programs.
In these situations, the process is typically initiated by the employer or HR department. Clinics may receive forms requesting confirmation of diagnoses or descriptions of functional limitations. Eligibility and approval decisions are made by the employer, not by the treating clinician.
Short-Term and Long-Term Disability Insurance
Other patients have private disability insurance through their employer. These policies are administered by insurance companies with their own criteria and documentation requirements.
From a primary care perspective, this often involves requests for medical records or specific forms. The clinician’s role is to provide accurate documentation when appropriate. The insurer determines whether benefits are approved.
Social Security Disability (SSDI or SSI)
When patients say they are “applying for disability,” they may be referring to Social Security Disability. This is a federal process with strict eligibility criteria and a lengthy timeline.
Primary care clinicians do not approve or deny Social Security Disability claims. The Social Security Administration reviews medical records from multiple sources and may require additional evaluations before making a determination.
How State Laws and Clinic Policies Affect Your Role
Scope of practice and documentation authority vary by state, and many organizations have specific internal policies regarding disability paperwork. Some clinics limit which forms clinicians can complete or require certain processes to be followed.
Because of this variability, clinicians should avoid making commitments before confirming the clinic policy. When questions arise, it is appropriate to defer to clinic leadership or established protocols to ensure consistency and compliance.
What This Typically Looks Like in Primary Care Practice
In day-to-day practice, these visits often follow a similar pattern.
First, the clinician evaluates the patient medically, addressing symptoms, diagnoses, and functional concerns just as they would in any visit. The focus remains on providing appropriate medical care.
Next, the clinician clarifies which disability or leave process the patient is pursuing. Many patients have not yet contacted HR, an insurer, or the Social Security Administration. Helping them understand where to start is often part of the visit.
The clinician then explains their role clearly: medical evaluation and documentation, not eligibility determination. Setting this expectation early helps prevent frustration later.
Finally, depending on the situation, referrals may be considered. Formal disability evaluations are often more appropriately handled by specialists such as Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, psychiatry, psychology, or occupational medicine, depending on the reason for the request. Primary care frequently serves as the starting point rather than the endpoint in these processes.
Throughout, documentation should be accurate, objective, and complete, reflecting diagnoses, symptoms, and observed functional limitations without overstating or minimizing findings.
Why These Conversations Feel Especially Difficult for New NPs
Disability requests often arise during periods of medical decline, workplace stress, or burnout. Patients may feel vulnerable and unsure of what options they have. It’s natural that they look to their primary care clinician for guidance.
Understanding that your role is to provide medical care and documentation — rather than make determinations about benefits — can relieve much of the pressure. With experience, these conversations tend to feel more straightforward and less emotionally charged.
The Bottom Line for Nurse Practitioners
When a patient asks to go out on disability, you are not being asked to decide whether they qualify. You are being asked to evaluate their health, document your findings, and help them understand the appropriate processes.
Knowing how disability systems work — and where your responsibilities begin and end — protects you, supports your patients, and helps these conversations feel clearer and more sustainable over time.
This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Scope of practice, documentation authority, and disability-related responsibilities vary by state and organization. Clinicians should follow their local laws and clinic policies.
Medical-Legal Note: Documentation should be accurate, objective, and limited to clinical findings, diagnoses, and observed functional impact. Clinicians should follow state laws and organizational policies regarding disability-related documentation and referrals.
Clinic Scripts: Responding When a Patient Asks About Disability
The following scripts are designed to help clinicians respond clearly, consistently, and within scope when disability questions arise in primary care. They may be used verbatim or adapted to align with clinic policy and local regulations. These are based on my years of experience and my scope of work, so please ensure that you edit the scripts to suit your practice and scope best. Always check with your supervisor if you have questions or concerns!
Clarifying What the Patient Is Asking For
“When you say disability, can you tell me what your employer, insurer, or another organization has asked you to do?”
“Are you asking about time off work, employer disability benefits, or Social Security Disability?”
“Have you already spoken with HR or an insurance representative about next steps?”
Explaining the Clinician’s Role
“My role is to evaluate and treat your medical conditions and document how they’re affecting you. I don’t determine disability eligibility — that decision is made by your employer, insurer, or the Social Security Administration.”
“I can provide medical documentation based on my clinical evaluation if it’s requested, but I don’t approve or deny disability benefits.”
When the Patient Is Asking About Employer Leave or FMLA
“FMLA and employer leave are handled through your HR department. They usually provide specific forms if medical documentation is needed.”
“Once HR sends paperwork, we can review what’s being requested and follow our clinic’s process.”
When the Patient Is Asking About Short- or Long-Term Disability Insurance
“Disability insurance claims are reviewed by the insurance company. They may request medical records or forms, but they make the final decision.”
“If documentation is needed from us, the insurer usually contacts the clinic directly or provides specific paperwork.”
When the Patient Is Asking About Social Security Disability
“Social Security Disability is a federal process. The Social Security Administration determines eligibility, not individual clinicians.”
“They typically collect medical records from multiple providers as part of their review.”
Redirecting From “Taking Someone Out of Work”
“I can assess how your health is affecting your functioning at this time and document my findings, but I don’t make work or disability determinations.”
“Any documentation I provide reflects my objective clinical findings and medical judgment.”
When Specialty Evaluation May Be Involved
“In some situations, disability evaluations are often supported by specialists such as Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation or psychiatry, depending on the reason for the request.”
“Primary care is frequently the starting point for these conversations, with additional evaluations happening as needed.”
When Deferring to Clinic Policy
“Our clinic has specific policies around disability paperwork, and I want to make sure we follow those correctly.”
“I’ll need to confirm our clinic’s process before completing any forms.”
Closing the Conversation Supportively
“I hear that this is stressful, and I’m glad you brought it up.”
“We’ll focus on managing your health and helping you understand the appropriate next steps.”
If you liked this post, also check out:
© 2026 Real World NP. For educational and informational purposes only, see realworldnp.com/disclaimer for full details.
Sign up for your free
Ultimate Resource Guide for the New NP
Our favorite apps, podcasts, books & resources to save time and frustration in clinic.
